The One With The Unrequited Love
- Peaches James
- Apr 19
- 3 min read
Updated: Apr 20
There’s a kind of heartbreak that doesn’t come from a breakup.
It comes from the quiet realization that the love never quite existed—not fully, not mutually.
Not in the way it was imagined and not because the other person was cruel.
But because the bond was built more inside a craving than a connection.
Unrequited love isn’t always about someone who refuses to love back.
Sometimes it’s about loving a version of someone that only lived in the mind of the one who needed them.

Love or Longing?
When love feels scarce in childhood—when attention is inconsistent or affection comes with terms—people learn to cling.
They start to associate unpredictability with passion.
Distance becomes desire.
And the pain of absence feels more familiar than the peace of safety.
So when someone shows up, even in half-measures—kind words, soft eyes, occasional warmth—it can feel like magic.
It lights something up.
Not because it’s real, but because it mirrors something remembered.
Something wanted.
And that’s where longing slips in and dresses itself up as love.

The Fantasy and the Fallout
Some relationships exist more in projection than in presence.
A glance gets replayed.
A message gets re-read.
Moments get romanticized into entire realities.
And in that imagined closeness, the mind does something protective: it fills in the blanks.
It builds stories to explain the distance, to excuse the confusion, to maintain hope.
But love built in the mind isn’t grounded.
And when the other person doesn’t match the projection—doesn’t reciprocate, clarify, commit—it starts to hurt.
Not because they pulled away.
But because they were never all the way in.
The Part No One Talks About
It’s easy to sit with the pain of being unmet.
Harder to sit with the truth of why the bond was held onto for so long.
Sometimes the connection itself wasn’t even that deep.
Sometimes the feeling of being seen publicly—validated by proximity, liked, noticed, chosen in some small way—was enough to trigger something deeper.

That image became a symbol. of worth.
Of being desirable.
Of finally being seen by someone others respected or desired.
And in a world where survival sometimes depends on being “wanted,” that can feel intoxicating.
But it’s also fragile.
And it makes the connection feel bigger than it really was.
The Role of the Self
Here’s what healing asks: To not just blame the dynamic—but to examine the self.
To ask:
What part of me needed this so badly?
What version of me did I perform to keep it alive?
What effect did my survival response have on the connection?
Because yes—emotional intensity can be magnetic.
But it can also be overwhelming, unpredictable, destabilizing.
It’s okay to acknowledge that sometimes emotional need spilled into the space between.
That fear drove the closeness.
That sometimes the love felt isn’t just deep—it’s uncontained.
And that can make others step back—not because they don’t care, but because they’re protecting themselves from what they can’t hold.
That doesn’t make them cold.
It doesn’t make you bad. It just makes things honest.

The Exit as an Act of Care
Letting go isn’t a punishment.
It isn’t rejection.
It’s the most respectful thing someone can do when they realize:
The love they feel lives mostly in them.
The relationship doesn’t exist in reality.
And staying would mean continuing to bleed into someone else’s life.
Walking away can be care.
For both people.
Especially when that walk includes taking accountability for the intensity that may have made it harder to connect in the first place.
Walking Toward the Real Work
Letting go of a fantasy love hurts.
It forces the nervous system to face still-aching places that have long asked for soothing.
But it also clears space.
To come back to the root of it all: The version of the self still asking, “Am I worthy of being chosen?”
Because the answer is yes.
But that answer can’t come from the outside.
It comes from the work.
The slowing down.
The nervous system regulation.
The truth-telling.
The rebuilding of safety within.
This is not the story of being rejected.
It’s the story of choosing not to live in longing anymore.
Of not letting fantasy stand in for love.
Of walking away from what isn’t, so what is can finally heal.
Comments